Welcome to Teddy's Bully Bar
At Teddy's Bully Bar, we celebrate the camaraderie of good food and great company. Nestled in the heart of Oyster Bay, our establishment invites guests into a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for families and friends alike. Our menu features a delightful array of classic favorites, from savory nachos to delectable tacos, ensuring a joyful dining experience. The bar showcases creative cocktails like the Bully Bramble and the Angry Rita, crafted with care by our skilled mixologists. Guests consistently praise the friendly staff and vibrant ambiance, making each visit feel like a cherished gathering. Join us at Teddy's Bully Bar, where every meal is a celebration.
Teddy's Bully Bar: Reviews & Ratings
Went there for a few drinks one day and had lunch the next day. Gina was a great conversationalist. Will be back when we are in the area.
Friendly and outgoing staff! Our bartender, Fran, was fantastic, she mixed up a variety of delicious drinks, and every single one was a hit. We stopped by after touring the Roosevelt estate, and it was the perfect way to wrap up the whole Teddy Roosevelt experience. The food was fresh, flavorful, and absolutely hit the spot.
Dropped in late on a cold Saturday afternoon. Inviting bar area with fire crackling and spacious seating area; dining area in back where young family was playing a card game after a late lunch. Enjoyed a Guinness and fantastic bowl of hearty clam chowder.
I visited this place on Halloween. The music has been fantastic this night . A lot of people. The food was fine and drink really well. The bartender has good taste ,bur problems with math. I can understand. It's been a lot more people than night . So, in general, great time.
Fantastic service and a beautifully designed space! The oysters are fresh, and the fish burger is a must-try. While the lobster soup was a bit too sweet for my taste, the overall experience was excellent. May every meal be shared with love and gratitude, and may His presence bring peace and prosperity to all who enter. God bless you!
Fran was a fantastic bartender and food was . Would drink here again.
I started off looking for “just a bar” and stumbled across Teddy’s. What I found was a modern interior with a pleasant staff that was willing to accommodate anything and everything. Oyster Bay is not the friendliest place for minorities but genuinely, I feel like I am home at Teddy’s. Thank you!
Such a fun atmosphere! Great food and drinks, Fran is the best bartender!
Location
-
46 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, United States Hotline: +1 516-408-5339
Welcome to Teddy's Bully Bar, a delightful escape located at 46 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771. At this captivating venue, you’ll discover more than just a bar; it’s a celebration of flavor and camaraderie. With a warm atmosphere where the fire crackles and conversations flow freely, Teddy's has quickly become a local favorite for both food enthusiasts and casual diners alike.
Teddy's Bully Bar proudly serves an impressive selection of cocktails that elevate the dining experience. From the refreshing Paloma, a zesty mix of tequila, grapefruit, and lime juice, to the classic Manhattan, each sip is crafted with precision. The vibrant Espresso Martini offers a delightful twist for coffee lovers, while the French 75 delivers a touch of elegance with its effervescent charm.
- Signature Cocktails:
- Paloma - $12.00
- French 75 - $14.00
- The Alice - $12.00
- Bloody Mary - $13.00
- Espresso Martini - $13.00
- Manhattan - $14.00
The food menu is equally enticing, featuring gourmet sandwiches that are sure to appeal to a variety of palates. The Authentic Cuban Sandwich stands out with its slow-roasted pork, Swiss cheese, and pickles, making it a must-try. For those craving something with a kick, the Spicy Chicken Sandwich delivers bold flavors thanks to its spicy chipotle mayo and jalapeños. Each dish comes with a side of crispy french fries, creating a satisfying meal for any time of day.
- Notable Sandwiches:
- Authentic Cuban Sandwich - $20.00
- BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich - $19.00
- Spicy Chicken Sandwich - $19.00
For those looking for lighter options, Teddy's Bully Bar offers refreshing greens like the classic Caesar Salad, dressed generously with creamy Caesar dressing, and the charming House Salad, bursting with mixed greens and honey balsamic dressing. Priced at $14.00 each, these salads provide a perfect complement to your meal.
- Greens:
- Caesar Salad - $14.00
- House Salad - $14.00
Patrons rave about the warm and welcoming atmosphere at Teddy's, where friendly bartenders like Gina and Fran create an inviting experience with their engaging personalities and expertly crafted drinks. One visitor, Rob Thies, noted, “Gina was a great conversationalist,” while Eric Hemmele praised the friendly service and the fresh, flavorful food that perfectly capped off his day of touring the nearby Roosevelt estate.
Whether you're stopping in for a quick drink or settling down for a satisfying meal, Teddy's Bully Bar offers a bit of everything—good company, exceptional drinks, and memorable dishes that keep you coming back. Come experience the inviting charm of Teddy's Bully Bar, where every visit promises good times and great flavors!